Engineered vs. Solid Hardwood Flooring: Which is better?

Choosing the ideal flooring type for your project is exciting and challenging. But the tricky part is which one to consider for your home.

 

The decision often comes down to two popular options: engineered hardwood and solid wood flooring.

 

Every type of flooring has unique perks and is ideal for durability and versatility. Consider choosing engineered hardwood vs. solid wood flooring for a stable solution for different environments.

 

Engineered hardwood combines a top layer of real wood with a plywood base. Solid wood flooring flaunts timeless beauty and authenticity. Both types of flooring offer warmth and richness to your spaces.

 

In this blog, we will explore the key differences between engineered hardwood and solid wood flooring, the pros and cons of these flooring types, and essential factors in choosing the right flooring type.

 

Start Reading!

What is Engineered Hardwood Flooring?

The engineered hardwood core is made from high-quality plywood or high-density fiberboard (HDF). The surface consists of a slim layer of hardwood and veneer attached with adhesives to the plywood core.

 

Various kinds of wood are commonly used to surface engineered hardwood flooring.

 

It includes hickory, pecan, birch, maple, oak, American beech, walnut, cherry, and pine. The cross-hatched layers of plywood enhance the floor’s dimensional stability.

 

These layers ensure that the floor is less likely to swell, crack, or warp when exposed to moisture. The most durable engineered wood flooring offers easy installation and can last between 20 and 30 years.

 

Are you wondering what engineered flooring is? Engineered flooring includes different layers of hardwood in one plank. In quality engineered flooring, the upper layer is made of sliced or sawn hardwood veneer, resembling solid hardwood.

 

Under the top layer, multiple layers of wood or plywood are bonded and laminated perpendicularly.
The final result is dimensionally stable and more capable of handling moisture, temperature fluctuations, and humidity. It is ideal for basements with a moisture barrier, concrete slab setups, and radiant heating systems.

 

Engineered hardwood thickness varies between 3/8-inch and 1/2-inch. Standard widths range from 3 1/4 inches to 5 inches and more. Generally, planks wider than 5″ are available in engineered hardwood. Its overall dimensional stability dramatically enhances performance.

 

Engineered hardwood is mostly factory-finished. It undergoes several applications of highly durable finishes (matte, high-gloss, and semi-gloss). You might choose surface finishes like hand-scraped, distressed, or wire-brushed.

 

Engineered wood is easier to install than solid hardwood. Any size can be stapled and nailed, and it can also be glued or floated as required.

Pros of Engineered Hardwood Flooring

Engineered hardwood flooring offers several advantages, making it a popular choice for homeowners. It combines beauty and practicality, making it a smart flooring choice.

 

Let us take a look into the benefits –

1. Environmentally Conscious

 

Engineered hardwood utilizes less hardwood for each plank compared to solid wood flooring. It is a vital advantage of engineered hardwood flooring when choosing interesting or uncommon wood species.

 

Moreover, these floors are environmentally friendly and sustainable due to minimal to no sawdust or harmful adhesives.

2. Easy to Install

 

Engineered wood floors are simple and fast to install. Engineered hardwood is attached and can be floated on top of an existing subfloor. Planks can interlock above the existing floor instead of being glued or nailed down.

 

By hiring professionals, you can ensure the installation will be completed seamlessly.

 

Glue-down or staple-down installations requires expert hands. We suggest hiring professionals to prevent complications and ensure the highest accuracy and quality. A correctly installed floor is vital for an extended lifespan.

3. Potentially Long Lifespan

 

Well-installed and maintained high-quality engineered hardwood can last about twenty to thirty years.

 

Careful upkeep and attention to the veneer are essential for ensuring the longevity of your engineered hardwood. Its durability is one of the top benefits of engineered hardwood floors.

 

Pre-finished boards provide a durable UV-cured finish. This finish is so strong that it does not require refinishing, only resurfacing, without involving sanding down to the lower layers.

4. Abundant Design Options

 

Contemporary engineered hardwood and solid hardwood resemble each other in appearance and texture. Engineered hardwood provides designs in the same wood species.

 

You can design a timeless herringbone or chevron parquet pattern, horizontal lines, or a distinctive pattern inspired by your creativity.

 

Exotic woods, such as Brazilian Cherry or Brazilian Teak, can be found at a higher price than local species like oak, maple, and hickory.

 

If you want these wood species, choose engineered hardwood flooring. It costs less than the same solid hardwood species, as they use less solid wood.

Cons of Engineered Hardwood Flooring

Engineered hardwood flooring has gained popularity among homeowners because of its sturdiness, cost-effectiveness, and appealing looks. However, like any other flooring choice, engineered wood flooring has drawbacks.

1. High Maintenance

 

The top layer of engineered hardwood is identical to solid hardwood, requiring equivalent maintenance. To safeguard the finish, sweep often, maintain a dry floor, and avoid strong chemicals.

2. Susceptible to Scratches and Dents

 

Engineered hardwood is resilient, but it will eventually get scratched and dented. Carefully consider the hardwood type of the veneer you select.

 

Consider its strength and the level of foot traffic in the space. Use rugs and furniture sliders to safeguard the surface from scratches.

Ideal Applications of Engineered Hardwood Flooring

 

Engineered hardwood floors are a versatile and stylish choice for different areas in your residence. Their unique design makes them ideal for locations like basements, kitchens, and other areas. They are perfect for both residential and commercial properties.

 

The ideal applications of this flooring are –

 

• Bedroom: Hardwood floors are an ideal option. They enhance the beauty and worth of a home and can suit any bedroom style.
• Basement:  Engineered flooring is ideal for well-finished basements. These floors feature a multi-layer design, providing increased stability. It reduces concern about contraction and expansion due to variations in temperature and humidity.
• Bathroom: Engineered hardwood flooring is a superior option for bathrooms. Plywood or solid wood bottom resists moisture effectively and maintains dimensional stability. An engineered hardwood floor performs effectively in large, well-ventilated bathrooms, experiencing minimal foot traffic.
• Living room: Engineered hardwood floors can be sanded and refinished several times, ensuring they maintain their value over time.

What Is Solid Flooring?

According to its name, solid hardwood flooring consists of planks crafted from solid wood.

Solid hardwood usually measures 3/4 inches thick and ranges in width from 2 1/2 inches to 5 inches.  It was primarily site-finished.

 

The wood was delivered, installed, sanded, and finished on-site. It is now commonly pre-finished at the factory, resulting in a more straightforward and cleaner installation process at home.

 

You will never see solid hardwood set up as a floating floor. Instead, the boards are secured with nails or staples. Any solid hardwood that is 5″ or greater must be glued and nailed, increasing labor expenses.

 

Solid wood flooring doesn’t go well with water. For this reason, you will not be able to install it underground in basements or in any area where moisture is present. Instead, you can install this flooring in rooms and corridors above ground.

 

One of the perks of installing solid hardwood is that it can be sanded and refinished numerous times over its lifespan.

Pros of Solid Hardwood Flooring

Pros	Cons
Seamless Installation – High-quality processing ensures a precise fit. Prefinished options make installation easier and more affordable.	High Initial Cost – More expensive than other flooring options; professional installation adds to the cost.
Easy to Clean – Doesn’t trap much dirt, dust, or debris; simple cleaning routine with vacuuming and mopping.	Susceptibility to Moisture and Humidity – Expands and contracts with humidity changes, leading to warping, buckling, or gaps.
High-Quality Look – Offers a luxurious and timeless aesthetic; enhances the feeling of space.	Regular Maintenance Required – Prone to scratches, dents, and scuffs, requiring routine care and occasional refinishing.
Strength and Durability – Kiln-dried and manufactured to industry standards; withstands heavy foot traffic.	Limited Installation Areas – Not ideal for basements or moisture-prone areas; needs stable indoor humidity levels.
Great Long-Term Investment – Increases home value, aids in resale, and has a lasting return on investment.

When choosing flooring for your home, solid hardwood flooring stands out as a timeless and elegant option.  Let us take a look into the advantages –

1. Seamless installation  

 

High-quality hardwood floors are carefully processed, ensuring an even and reliable fit. The selection between finished and unfinished hardwood flooring is crucial. Installing prefinished solid hardwood floors is significantly simpler and more affordable.

2. Easy to clean

 

Hardwood floors are simple to clean since they do not gather much dirt, dust, or debris. A weekly cleaning routine includes vacuuming, mopping, and drying the floor.

3. High-quality look

 

In addition to an elegant, luxurious appearance, solid hardwood floors provide the charm, allure, and worth of wood, which remains timeless. These are also known for creating a spacious appearance in any setting.

4. Strength and durability

 

Durable hardwood floors kiln-dried, produced, laid down, and polished to industry standards last for generations. They can withstand busy work environments and substantial foot traffic. Quality solid hardwood floors are resilient, durable, and built for lasting use.

5. A great long-term investment

 

Choosing solid hardwood flooring enhances the worth of your property. It is an excellent long-term investment and can provide a compelling resale point. The flooring’s original installation expense is exceeded. It also facilitates faster sales and results in increased prices during resale.

Cons of Solid Hardwood Flooring

Although solid hardwood flooring offers enduring beauty and strength to any area, it’s essential to consider its cons before finalizing a choice.

1. High Initial Cost

 

Considering material and installation expenses, solid hardwood is more expensive than other flooring choices. It is frequently advised to have a professional installation to ensure quality and durability, which increases the total cost. This upfront cost is a disadvantage for homeowners with a budget constraint.

2. Susceptibility to Moisture and Humidity

 

A primary limitation of solid hardwood is its vulnerability to moisture. Because it is constructed from solid wood, it swells and shrinks with changes in humidity and temperature.

 

As a result, it faces warping, buckling, or spaces between boards. It is unsuitable for moisture-sensitive areas such as basements, bathrooms, or any location where water damage could be an issue.

 

It is most appropriate for spaces that maintain consistent indoor temperatures, including living rooms, bedrooms, and dining spaces.

3. Regular Maintenance Required

 

Though resilient, solid hardwood can still be susceptible to scratches, dents, and scuffs. It is mainly found in busy areas or households with pets and young kids.

 

Even though it can be restored, homeowners should carry out routine maintenance like sweeping and periodic polishing to maintain the appearance of their floors.

 

With time, more profound scratches or blemishes might require refinishing.

4. Limited Installation Areas

 

Because it is sensitive to moisture, solid hardwood is inappropriate for every part of the house. It is advised not to install it below ground level, like in basements or regions with excessive humidity.

 

For residences with notable seasonal humidity variations, following steps like keeping a steady indoor humidity level is necessary to avoid damage.

Ideal Applications of Solid Hardwood Flooring

Solid wood flooring is a very adaptable and favored option for numerous uses. It is known for its inherent beauty, strength, and enduring charm.

 

Here are the ideal applications of solid hardwood flooring:

1. Residential Properties:

 

Solid hardwood flooring is frequently installed in different areas of residential properties, including living rooms, bedrooms, dining areas, and hallways.

 

Its welcoming and attractive design fosters a cozy ambiance. It is perfect for homeowners seeking a timeless and sophisticated residence appearance.

2. Commercial Spaces:

 

Solid hardwood flooring is appropriate for commercial areas, such as offices, restaurants, hotels, and retail shops. It brings elegance and professionalism to these spaces, fostering a friendly and hospitable atmosphere for customers and staff.

3. Public Buildings:

 

Many public structures, such as museums, libraries, and government buildings, choose solid wood flooring. It is a sought-after option for its aesthetic appeal and durability.

 

The lush and inviting hues of wooden floors elevate the overall atmosphere and evoke a feeling of timelessness and genuineness.

4. Educational Institutions:

 

Solid hardwood flooring is a perfect option for educational institutions, such as schools and universities. Its strength enables it to endure significant foot traffic, ensuring longevity even in high-traffic zones.

 

Solid wood flooring is ideal for classrooms, hallways, and communal areas. It is hypoallergenic and simple to maintain, making it a sanitary option for these settings.

Key Differences Between Engineered Wood Flooring Vs Solid Hardwood Flooring

Feature	Engineered Hardwood Flooring	Solid Hardwood Flooring
Appearance	Prefinished with limited colors and species; wider planks; beveled edges create subtle grooves.	Available in prefinished and unfinished options; tight seams; wider range of colors and species.
Cost	More affordable, starting at ~$4.50 per sq. ft.; made from lower-cost wood like oak or maple.	Prices vary based on grade; rough-hewn to premium options; prefinished solid wood is more budget-friendly.
Lifespan	Lasts 20–30 years; fine scratches can be sanded, but deep ones are hard to repair.	Lasts 30–100 years with proper maintenance; allows multiple sanding and refinishing.
Sound	Produces a hollow sound, especially when installed as a floating floor.	Quieter with better acoustic properties; absorbs echoes and disperses sound.
Water Resistance	More water-resistant than solid hardwood but not waterproof; resists humidity due to plywood core.	Not ideal for humid or damp areas; can warp and swell due to moisture.
Care & Cleaning	Sweeping, vacuuming, and damp mopping recommended; avoid steam cleaning.	Sweeping, dry mopping, and occasional damp mopping with approved cleaners; no steam cleaning.
Environmental Impact	Uses less traditional wood; incorporates byproducts but includes adhesives that release VOCs; non-biodegradable.	Requires more tree harvesting but can be repurposed, recycled, and is biodegradable

Are you planning to renovate an entire home or just sprucing up a single room? Understanding the difference between engineered hardwood and solid wood flooring is essential to achieving your space’s perfect look and feel.

 

When selecting the appropriate flooring for your home, it is crucial to comprehend the distinctions between solid and engineered hardwood flooring. Each choice provides unique benefits and visual charm.

 

Although they are built in different ways and serve various requirements, we will explore the main distinctions between solid wood and engineered hardwood floors, helping you make an informed choice for your space.

 

The differences between solid hardwood flooring vs engineered wood flooring are –

1. Appearance

 

Appearance is a crucial factor to consider when choosing between engineered hardwood floors and solid wood.

 

Engineered hardwood flooring mainly comes prefinished, and there is a lesser range of available colors and species.

 

These floorboards tend to be wider than solid hardwood. Some prefinished engineered hardwood flooring comes with slightly beveled edges, creating subtle grooves between the planks.

 

Solid hardwood flooring generally has very tight seams between boards. It offers a wider range of colors and species than engineered hardwood flooring. Solid hardwood is available in prefinished and unfinished boards.

2. Cost

 

Evaluating the cost is vital to choosing between engineered wood vs solid hardwood flooring.

 

Engineered hardwood floors are more affordable than solid hardwood floors. They begin at approximately $4.50 per square foot and are made from more affordable wood types, such as oak or maple.

 

Solid hardwood flooring prices differ by grade, ranging from rough-hewn cabin to grade.

 

Grading impacts the visual characteristics of wood (flaws, knots, streaks, and wormholes) rather than its species or quality. Prefinished solid wood flooring is considered to be more affordable.

3. Lifespan

 

It is critical to consider durability and lifespan when choosing solid wood vs engineered hardwood floors.

 

Engineered hardwood floors generally last for about 20 to 30 years. Fine scratches can be gently sanded away. The deep scratches that tear through the delicate veneer are hard to repair.

 

Solid hardwood lasts 30 to 50 years and even up to 100 years. It allows for multiple sanding and refinishing processes. However, solid hardwood flooring must be maintained in a dry condition.

 

Solid hardwood flooring endures significantly longer than engineered hardwood flooring with proper maintenance.

4. Sound

 

Engineered hardwood floors produce a hollower sound than solid wood floors. They can be secured or fastened to the subfloor or laid down as floating floors. However, they do not absorb noise effectively when utilized as floating floors. Moreover, the plywood foundation is not as dense as that of solid hardwood.

 

Solid hardwood floors tend to be quieter than engineered hardwood floors. They exhibit superior acoustic qualities compared to engineered hardwood. Their density absorbs echoes, while their firmness disperses the sound uniformly throughout the space.

 

Hardwood flooring is fixed to the subfloor, providing stability. When solid hardwood flooring is installed, the boards creak and squeak as they adjust.

 

If creaking persists after a few months, it could be due to an uneven subfloor or a problem with the installation.

5. Water Resistance

 

While considering the difference between engineered hardwood vs solid hardwood, water resistance plays a key role.

 

Engineered hardwood floors are more water-resistant than solid hardwood floors and are not waterproof.

 

It excels in humid environments because its plywood design enhances stability and reduces the chances of warping. Every layer of wood in the plywood is positioned at a 90-degree angle to the adjacent ply.

 

Even though engineered hardwood flooring is more water-resistant than solid hardwood, it should not be placed in moist areas, such as bathrooms.

 

Engineered hardwood flooring starts to delaminate if it is subjected to water for an extended period.

 

On the other hand, it is not advisable to install solid hardwood directly on concrete slabs. Moisture moving through the concrete can cause the hardwood to swell and warp. It is also not advisable to install a solid hardwood floor in damp areas like bathrooms.

6. Care and Cleaning

 

Care and cleaning play a vital role in understanding the difference between engineered hardwood and hardwood.

 

You can clean and maintain engineered hardwood floors by sweeping or vacuuming them daily. Use a slightly damp mop or an industry-grade commercial cleaner. Do not use a steam cleaner on engineered wood flooring.

 

For solid hardwood flooring cleaning, you can sweep, dry mop, or vacuum it. Use a damp mop only when needed, and utilize only an approved cleaner for wood. Avoid using steam to clean wood floors.

7. Environmental Impact

 

Engineered hardwood flooring features only a thin layer of traditional wood on top of its plywood or HDF core. Compared to solid hardwoods, it requires less tree usage per plank.

 

It utilizes the byproducts and waste from different wood production processes to create its boards. It is also produced with adhesives and resins that release gases or have volatile organic compounds.

 

Engineered hardwood cannot decompose, has a short lifespan, and ultimately goes to landfills.

 

Compared to its engineered counterpart, solid hardwood necessitates harvesting a greater number of trees. However, solid hardwood can be repurposed, reused, or recycled into different items.

 

When it requires to be disposed of at the end of its life cycle, it is biodegradable and does not result in landfill waste.

Factors to Consider While Choosing the Right Flooring for Your Needs

Selecting the right flooring for your space is a crucial decision that impacts the aesthetics and functionality of your home or office. With various options available, evaluating different factors to suit your specific needs and lifestyle is essential.

 

Here are the key points to consider:

1. Durability and Maintenance

 

The durability of flooring is crucial, mainly in high-traffic zones. Consider using engineered hardwood or solid hardwood that withstand damage and deterioration over time.

 

Considering maintenance needs, specific flooring options, like carpets, might need frequent cleaning and care. Evaluate your living space and select a flooring option that matches your everyday habits and requirements.

2. Comfort and Insulation

 

Comfort is essential, especially in spaces like bedrooms and living areas. The insulation characteristics of the flooring should be taken into account.

 

Consider the materials with superior thermal insulation to help maintain room temperature and enhance energy efficiency.

3. Aesthetic Appeal

 

The aesthetic appeal of flooring significantly affects the general atmosphere of an area. When choosing flooring, take into account the design style of your residence.

 

Whether you favor classic wood finishes or contemporary designs, make sure the flooring enhances your current decor.

 

Choose colors, materials, and designs that align with your idea and elevate the visual appeal of your surroundings.

4. Cost and Budget

 

Flooring choices differ significantly in cost, making it essential to set a budget before starting the selection process. Although premium materials provide durability and visual charm, budget-friendly solutions can also yield excellent outcomes.

 

Be sure to consider installation expenses, as specific flooring types require expert installation, which can potentially increase the overall cost.

 

Evaluate your choices thoughtfully and select flooring offering the greatest return on your investment.

5. Environmental Considerations

 

With growing sustainability awareness, homeowners are now considering the environmental effects of their flooring selections.

 

They opt for sustainable materials to reduce their carbon impact. Choosing environmentally friendly flooring materials helps the planet and improves indoor air quality.

 

Consider these elements to make a well-informed decision. Choose the ideal type that aligns with your practical requirements and enhances your design tastes.

Elevate Your Living Space with Exclusive Flooring Options!

Are you wondering if engineered flooring is as good as hardwood? Both engineered hardwood floors and solid wood floors make excellent flooring options.

 

Engineered hardwood flooring is generally more suitable for places with moisture issues. It provides cost-efficiency solutions with enhanced control over your desired appearance.

 

In contrast, solid hardwood floors offer unrivaled natural beauty, durability, and the option to refinish several times.

 

It is essential to evaluate your individual requirements and choices, as well as your financial constraints, before reaching a conclusion.

 

At iFlooringUSA, we offer various flooring requirements for residential and commercial areas.
We are experienced in the flooring sector and are highly skilled in installing the ideal flooring. Get seamless installation in your area while maximizing cost efficiency.

 

You can choose from our range of flooring options, such as hardwood, vinyl, and carpet. We use premium products from leading manufacturers in the industry to design customized commercial or residential spaces.

 

Reach out to our experts and select the appropriate kind of wood flooring for your dedicated space.